Articles · Humor/ Editorial · Gaming - In General

7 Things About Beauty and the Beast

Recently attended a showing of the 2017 Beauty and the Beast starring Emma Watson. The following are my thoughts on the movie

75 xp 2,003 views

1. Live Action

The live action movie is almost completely a remake of the 1991 animated feature. This is a good thing, as it is immediately familiar, the characters are instantly accessible, the song and dance numbers are all intact, and the movie is very well presented. As a live action version of the cartoon, it does fantastic and delivers everything nostalgia wants. It does go off the rails in the few instances when it tries to add in a new song or two. This is largely forgivable as the sour note new additions are easily overshadowed by Luke Evans singing Gaston's song, and Be Our Guest.

2. CGI, and CGI Bullshit

There are certain characters who are simply not capable of being practical effects, like Mrs Potts, Lumiere, etc. After the initial shock of the new character designs is realized, their banter and actions ease you into believing they are who they are, and the CGI is acceptable to the suspension of disbelief. Unfortunately, Beast is a CGI bukkake fuck up, and for me was eye searing to look at. I have seen some of the test shots for a practical effects (prosthetics and animatronics) and these looked solid, but were crapped on by the director. (Yes, I know people)

3. Awards

The movie looks great, and when the awards season rolls around, it is going to rack up some fancy trophies. None of it will be for acting, but for costume design, special effects, music score, and so forth. Technically, visually, it is a fantastic movie. The costumes are simply gorgeous, from the provincial folk, to the effete nobles of Prince Adam's soiree. The sets of the movie are also superb.

4. Emma Watson

One of the two reasons I wanted to see this movie was Emma Watson. I have a basic-bro infatuation with her, and I am a fan of the 91 animated film. Unfortunately, after the CGI Beast (ugh) Watson is the next worst thing in the movie. For what should be a character vehicle for her, she comes across and stiff and wooden. It makes sense, as most of her scenes are done with minimal human actors, and were filled in post production. It is largely the same phenomenon that plagued Natalie Portman in the Star Wars prequels. A fantastic actor or actress can only do so much with green screen and not actually being able to react to things because they were added later digitally. That being said, while she doesn't really carry Belle's je ne sais quoi, she sticks the singing parts, looks the part, and delivers a good performance.

5. Luke Evans

Luke Evans absolutely owned his role as Gaston. Part of this was embracing a bombastic jerk of a character, plus most of his work with with other actors and not digital creations. The story does play up Gaston as darker and much more of a villain, rather than just basically an alpha dude-bro. He looks the part, he acts the part, and fully believes himself to be the hero of the story.

6. LeFou

The movie stirred up some controversy with LeFou being the first openly gay character in a Disney movie. I thing this is something of a dramatically overplayed hand because if you watched the 91 cartoon, it was fairly obvious that he was gay in that movie also, but more buffoonish. In the new movie he channels a young Oliver Platt and is charming, goofish, and gay. On the other hand, the protests against the movie for this reason are frankly ridiculous because despite the headline of first openly gay Disney character, there is zero sexual tension, no sweat man-ass pounding, and the banter between LeFou and Gaston is fun and camp.

7. Goofs

While enjoyable, the movie was not engrossing, and I was able to find windows to throw goof commentary in. Most of this revolved around either Watson's work as Hermonie Grainger (Wandering through the Beast's castle, or the forbidden West Wing ~ Shit, this isn't Hogarts.) or around the fact that a largely British cast was performing a traditional French fairy tale. One scene showed Belle teaching a young girl of the village to read (the villagers negative response is basically a stand in for the women's rights movement) and my commentary revolved around asking why in provincial France Belle was teaching the girls how to read English.

Overall, a highly enjoyable movie. If you liked the 91 animated film, this is true to the spirit and look of the original. If you disliked the original, then the live action is probably not going to be an improvement.

4.25/5

Scrolls

0 scrolls

Twists, chapters, and details meant to stream with the submission — not general discussion.

No scrolls yet — leave one if you have a twist worth keeping.

Sign in to plant an idea scroll.

Award XP

Enjoyed this? Sign in to thank Scrasamax with blade clashes — 5 XP each, up to 25.

5 10 15 20 25

Sign in to award XP.

Rare mark

Hall of Honour

for 7 Things About Beauty and the Beast

The Hall of Honour is your mark on a submission you believe is frick’n awesome — so good you would jump in front of a dragon’s breath to protect the scroll it is written on.

Bestowing HoH also highlights it on the front of the Citadel for about a day, so others see the recognition it earned.

You may bestow HoH on the same submission up to your level (with a short wait between strikes). Five distinct HoH voters raise a work to Golden.

Your shelf

Favor

for 7 Things About Beauty and the Beast

Sign in to Grant your Favor on work worth keeping.

Your Realm

Claim

for 7 Things About Beauty and the Beast

Sign in and Crown a Realm to Claim this as a Holding for the table.

Discussion

6 comments

Reader talk, questions, and feedback — not scrolls.

  1. Moonlake

    Must say that I was tempted to watch it when I saw the ad for it on a bus given my memory of the 91 Disney cartoon version which I enjoyed immensely. This seems to tempt me further. On the other hand, I don't remember any other characters from that movie except for the Beauty and the Beast.

    0 xp Reply +XP
    1. Scrasamax reply

      They are planning to live action Mulan, but removing the songs and humor

      0 xp Reply +XP
    2. Moonlake reply

      Bought the tickets to watch b&b coming Monday, never saw Mulan cos I had outgrew cartoons by then but my best friends seems to like Mulan a lot.

      0 xp Reply +XP
  2. axlerowes

    0 xp Reply +XP
  3. Cheka Man

    0 xp Reply +XP
  4. ScorpionJinx

    0 xp Reply +XP

Sign in to join the discussion.

Other takes

none yet

No other takes yet — the best compliment on the Citadel is a Retelling.

Bonds

none yet

Curated bonds across the Citadel. Kindred Favors are another thread in the same weave.

No bonds yet.

The graph

Bind a Bond

from 7 Things About Beauty and the Beast

Know a piece that belongs with this one? Bind them together so every reader who finds one can find the other. Choose how they are bound.

Sign in to bind Bonds.

Browse Articles Seek the Citadel