Voting
Disjoined thoughts:
* The voting text for 3.0 reads 'Good solid idea, nothing fancy, just a great, useable, quality submission.' If Strolen wanted to change that, he'd do it. Since he hasn't, I take that at face value. That means a 3.0 is a quality, solid submission. From the comments and posts I've read, a number of folks get bent out of shape if their average drops below 4.0, and I've seen a few get pissy the further below a freaking ‘5' they get. I don't understand that.
* A ‘5' is PERFECT. It can't be bettered, no matter how much time you lavish on it. It's professional quality, the sort of writing I'd be happy to pay for. So far I've given out exactly two. I don't figure on handing out many.
* This is a site that encourages you to vote and comment on subs. Too bad this one doesn't allow those with thin skins to disable comments or voting, but I figure people who hate negative comments or votes lower than they like should avoid posting their stuff publicly for others to review.
* Not every question needs to be answered. The abilities of that NPC are a big secret, and players aren't expected to figure it out? Great. I don't need to know either. I don't mind subs with a bit of mystery to them, and that leaves some questions for me to answer.
What I Like:
* I do gritty fantasy, supers and occasionally near-future SF. I don't do cyber/steampunk, horror, slapstick or dungeon fantasy. Low-voting a sub in a genre or style you hate or don't play is being a jerk, and I won't do it myself.
* What GMs don't need so much are broad ideas. We're usually pretty good at that. I don't need to go to a web site to decide that a mountain city quarries ornamental stone, that slavery's rife there, that it's a theocracy. Elements like those are easy to come up with. What's harder is the detail work. Does your sub have a dozen long paragraphs detailing the specific businesses of that city relating to stonecutting, quarrying and marketing? Do you detail the Slavers' Guild and its personalities, and the underground anti-slavery society and its personalities? What god rules the roost, what's its dogma and doctrine, who are the leading priests? That's the stuff I really like to see.
* Long subs. They don't offend me, and they don't intimidate me. If it's more than I can use, then I just don't use it all. Can't imagine why that'd be an issue.
* Stuff I not only could use, but am likely to use.
What I Don't Like:
* Vague, like above. Not much creativity there.
* Rotten logic. Civil courts use a 'reasonable person' test to judge the merits of a lawsuit. I use it to judge the logic of something. I find it wanting, I'll say so and my vote'll reflect it. (I don't buy into the 'it's fantasy so it can't be realistic' BS.)
* Bad grammar, spelling or punctuation. Look. This is a written medium. A typo here or there happens, sure, but if you can't be bothered to use proper English or proofread your stuff, then I can't be bothered to give you a good vote. (And c'mon. That's the real reason, isn't it? It's not that you're unable to spell, or that English is your second language, or that you're a busy bloke, is it? My wife's dyslexic, and she manages. It's that you can't be bothered.)
* Stuff that's not developed enough to be useful. If what you've put up is an incomplete rough draft, I'm gonna slam it like a trash can lid. Why not let that sub live on your computer until you've finished it?
* A lot of purple, florid prose. Fanfiction.net's where that belongs. After a certain point, flavor text gets to looking soggy.
Discussion
Discussion
No comments yet — be the first voice in the hall.
Observatory
Where Else It Leads
Observatory
Where Else It Leads
- Continue · Bound How I Vote Bound
- Continue · Same shelf 5 Room Dungeon Same shelf
- Continue · Use alongside Everlasting Chalk Use alongside
- Bond out · Kin Voting Practices Kin
- Bond in · Kin The Last Submission About Voting and Commenting Kin
- Mention My Voting Practices
- Alongside Gadreel & Mastema Corporation The G&M, or GaMa Corp, not to be confused with the larger GM corporation.
- Alongside What's in a Vote? What's in a Vote?
- Alongside Law of the Hammer In time long past the Citadel was new and innocent. As the years went on much was added to include the ability to vote and comment. Ever since then there has be…
- By Morningstar The Rainbow Sword 'So, my sisters.' I gazed out the clerestory window at the tableau in Court Square, and I made no doubt my gaze was as stony as were the rest of the Conclave. …
- By Morningstar How To Make Your Orcs TRULY Horrific Someone complained that orcs, in the campaigns he knew, were just cannon fodder -- there was nothing horrible, or terrifying, about them. This was the answer I…
- By Morningstar On LGBT Characters I had someone ask me, recently, why I not only allowed such characters in my campaign, but didn't seem to care that anyone wanted to do so. Parts of my respons…
Crossroads
Follow Another Path
Halls, shelves, and roads that leave this reading.
- Browse Articles This shelf
- Rules and Advice in Articles
- Citadel Help in Articles
- More by Morningstar Author tower
- Locations Category hall
- Lifeforms Category hall
- Items Category hall
- Organizations Category hall
- Dungeons Category hall
- NPCs Category hall
- Plots Category hall
- Systems Category hall
- Articles Category hall
- Crossroads Recent traffic
- Guildhall Guilds & Quests
- Seek the Citadel Find a piece
A very honest sub on your own voting practices and I appreciate that, thank you.