Making good submissions from bad ones

1. Making good submissions from bad ones

   #1

   Why not find a one star or half star submission and make something really good based on it?

2. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #2

   We'd need the approval of the original authors, assuming they're still around. 

3. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #3

   Not really - it might be polite to do so, but stuff is shared here and one of the reasons is to allow others to extend it.
   
   

4. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #4

   I attempted this the other day. It's actually quite a challenge.

5. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #5

   It was done at least once before, with the ghost of a certain demon.

6. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #6

   We have never had any issues with doing so before. The problem is not making something out of these submissions. The problem is making something GOOD out of them.

7. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #7

   I don't it's that hard, provided the author is willing to invest some time and effort on this challenge. Scras has demonstrated that it can be done.

8. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #8

   It's not too easy, but can be done. You don't have to change the original - simply write something based upon it, and link back.

9. Re: Making good submissions from bad ones

   #9

   Sounds like a solid idea may be difficult though.

Fields of Challenge · All categories · Guildhall