Fields of Challenge · Legacy archive
Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
-
Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#1Okay. Here are the finalists for the dungeon quest. Pick your top two, and post them in order of preference. You must vote to be eligible to win; however, you are not allowed to vote on your own entry. Voting closes on the 15th.
1. The Noil Ruins
2. The Mountain of Boats
3. Illyana's Palace
4. Mugama, the Gold That is Not
5. Covorane's Cave
-
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#2I'm surprised that AG's isn't up there... Tsk tsk, Citadellians.
1. Noil Ruins
2. Corvorane's Cave -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#3My vote:
1. Covorane's Cave
2. The Mountain of Boats -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#4Oh, what an oversight.
But to the voting:
1. The Mountain of Boats
2. Illyana's Palace -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#51. Mountain of Boats
2. Corovorane's Cave
2. Noil Ruins
Sorry, but I have been back and forth between Corovarane's and Noil for quite some time. In my eyes they both have unique qualities. When I first read the Cave it resembled the works of my youth too closely for me to be impressed, but in retrospect I see that Dozus did quite well.
So I changed my vote from Noil to Corvorane. Now I just don't know. Noil Ruins is extremely well written. I cannot decide.
I award both 0.5 points. If that is impossible, I refrain from giving the second vote. If so, it is just MoB that gets a vote from me. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#61. Noil Ruins
2. Mountain of Boats -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#71. Noil Ruins
2. Mugama, the Gold that is Not -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#81. The Mountain of Boats
2. Noil Ruins
Thats the only one I am voting for since the one I expected to be up there wasn't. I was just curious to know what determined which subs were placed up for voting? Out of 20+ subs only 5 were placed up. Now yes they do have higher votes but what about the subs with a higher number of HOH? Shouldn't that account for something as well?
Edit: I changed my vote. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#9I agree with Mourn.
I dont think 4.5 should be the prerequisite. Too many good dungeons left out. For Crawlers of the Dark to not be included is a travesty.
As is...
1- Mountain of Boats
2-Corvorane's Cave -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#101. Mugama, the Gold that is Not
2. Illyana's Palace -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#11Debate Moved: http://www.strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,3368.msg45702.html#msg45702
Let us keep this thread just for voting. Rules stand for this Quest. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#12Vote! -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#131. Corvorane's Cave
2. The Noil Ruins -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#14Come on, people. Vote. There's less than a week to go. Just a reminder, you DO have to vote to be eligible to win. Maggot, I'm looking at you. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#151- Mountain of Boats
2- Corvorane's Cave
I apologize for my tardy vote.. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#16Temporary Positions:
Mountain of Boats: 12
Noil Ruins: 8.5
Corvorane's Cave: 7.5
Mugama, the Gold that is Not: 3
Illyana's Palace: 2 -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#17I cant believe how few Citadelians bother to vote...sad really. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#18Vote, you filthy wretches! *whip crack* This quest won't vote on itself!
Seriously, why have a quest if you're not gonna vote on it, people? It takes like 2 seconds to vote, and not that much time reading these subs.
Well, it might take some time to read MoB, but... :wink: -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#19Yeeeessss, I sssssee it too Dozzzzussss! One point between you and glory everlasssssting!
Come on good people of the citadel! Cast your vote so that it may be settled once and for all! Who will be the runner up? Noil Ruins or that dread Cave of Corvorane? -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#20Okay, as it is after midnight, my time, voting is now closed.
In first place, we have The Mountain of Boats.
Runner up is The Noil Ruins.
Congratulations, dudes. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#21You LOVE me you, you REALLY LOVE me!
I'd like to thank my agent- Larry, you've been great; Oh god, I have so man ypeople to thank... -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#22Congratulations, gentlemen. Your rewards are well deserved. :D -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#23Congrats to everyone who entered and those who succeeded. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#24With so many entries of high quality, it is a shame that so few voted. Must be the summer low. -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#25CP & Scras, congrats! and to everyone who entered, cheers! A great bunch of subs!
Perhaps it is fitting for two of the Citadel's stalwart trailblazers to be the first on their block with a Strolen tee. :up: -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#26Strolen's Citadel second quest, Into the Dungeon was an outstanding success. An impressive 21 quest items were submitted and each author took away an extra 10xp from each of those submissions.
Without further ado, I give you your Strolenite voted top two Winners:
The Strolenite Medal of Honour and 100XP goes to:
CaptainPenguin for The Mountain of Boats
The Strolenite Badge of Recognition and 50XP goes to:
Scrasamax for The Noil Ruins
Congratulations to our winners!!! You shall be the proud recipients of a one of kind (OK, there are two of them) custom designed T-shirt donated by Murometz.
Thanks Muro!!! -
Re: Quest: Into the Dungeon Finalists
#27t-shirts coming..one week delay..just quit one job and started another, havent got a chance to drive 20 minutes to check them out...will do this week!! and there will be a picture posted!!
and what of Lifeform Quest?
how about the winning creature's name actually appears on tee!?
"The Cutsman Cometh"? or something like that?