Show All Votes on a Submission

1. Show All Votes on a Submission

   #1

   There are more no options because I have a feeling that is the way it might go. (No problem with that) I just want to know the reasoning behind it. If you want to see the votes feel free to tell me why in text. Figured the No people, well, it would be easier for them to just put a No on it instead of quantifying it. After all, they don't want us to see their votes on the Citadel anyway or else they wouldn't be voting that way.
   
   And, to clarify, if it changes to "No" then the vote will show ONLY IF the vote is made in conjunction with a post. If you want to hide your vote, you must vote without a comment. Voting with a comment will show your vote. So votes can still be visible for those that desire it, they just have to make a comment with the vote to make that happen.
   
   Let popular opion swing.
   
   (admins will be able to review votes if there are questions, this is about general public vote viewing)

2. Re: Show All Votes on a Submission

   #2

   I stand for my opinion.
   
   While I understand that some people might feel obliged to hand out better scores, or not vote at all, in the beginning, I believe this will pass quickly... I hope this will end the era of commentless voting. When I get a 2 I want to see WHY I got that. If I cannot have that I want to see WHO gave me that too. (Example: If it was MoonHunter or Scrasamax I would have been far more ok, than if it was CP. CP has the same tastes as me and is "up my street". MH and Scras, while excellent GMs and storywriters, love another part of RPGs entirely)
   
   Thus not only the votes are important: The voters are important too and tells me tons of about the success or failure of my post.
   
   And CP: You may still vote low on my stuff and do so with impunity. This is not a sweet talking club: It is a forum for feedback and helping each other improve. The scores help us do exactly that.

3. Re: Show All Votes on a Submission

   #3

   They don't, I think. The feedback does.
   
   *would rate his own reply a 2/5 - factual but very short* :)

4. Re: Show All Votes on a Submission

   #4

   I want to see the votes so I know what is pleasing who. :)

Bug Reports · All categories · Guildhall