Sacred Seal discussion · Legacy archive
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
-
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#1Dungeon Master's Guild
Site Title: Dungeon Master's Guild
Web Address: http://dmg.dfxwebs.com
Review the site and feel free to post your comments.
Description: The Dungeon Master's Guild is a Community website dedicated to gathering resources for D&D players and DMs from across the Web. DMG is a community both for developers of resources and for users. What is a Resource: to me, a resource is anything that helps you make your D&D game a better place. this includes links to websites with cool stuff, articles that can help your game, programs and forms and spreadsheets and maps you can use in-game. For developers, creators, and innovators, we are happy to host your files, post news articles about your resource, link to your files, online generator or download page. Basically, anything to spread the word about what you have done for the D&D community. Whether user or developer, we're dedicated to making this site a better place for all D&D players, so let me know if you have any suggestions for making the site a better place. Our goal is to create a great community for all 3E fans to come and enjoy and to give you a place to voice your opinion, whatever it may be. We take submissions for original material be it new races, classes, monsters or just helpful files as well as stories, poetry and art. We want to be more than just a storehouse of material, we want to be YOUR home for 3E on the net.
Home to the Dungeon Room Netbook, Archive of over 500+ files and growing everyday, a Message Forum devoted to the D&D DM/Player and also the newest project Realms End Tavern, LARP over the net. -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#2I agreed with many of the points in your critique, Strolen, and I think the site needs a lot of work still. More specifically, I think the alignment test is too long and the netbook could be better organised. It was a good site, but not yet worthy of the Seal...
ephemeralstability! -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#3They went through a lot of changes. Any more opinions?
Been a lot of updates and site changes so will hold off on my vote for a little longer since it has been in flux. I think it is looking promising though. -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#4The content is good, it's just the format the keeps changing. Although I like the new format. -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#5Before we can give it the Seal, it needs to get a more organized netbook, and for Lord Chaos's sake, stop changing their bloody format!
Yarr! -
It is okay
#6It is a nice site. Yet there is nothing here that I have not seen in one form or another on other sites. It does not have more of everything than other sites. Nothing stands out as special or important. The only thing going for it is that is is all here at one url.
It does have a great deal of potential. We are looking at it in "Elementry school". When it gets to High School it will be a great site. (forgive the metaphor) Of course this all depends on if it is still here. -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#7The coolest part was the Dungeon Room that I loved just looking at a couple at a time. But now it is in pdf format and I honestly don't really like pdfs. I want to look at the stuff, not have to download it and then have to deal with yet another file on my computer. Bring back the web pages of Dungeon Room.
Book of Shadows is hidden. I submitted a couple things but it is hard to submit blindly when you don't know what is already done. There could be a lot of needless duplication by forcing people to submit and then 'maybe' they will be able to see it.
Dice tales were cool too, now annoying pdf.
Getting to the stuff is too much work. At least they are not pdfs in a zip file because that would cause me to write it off completely.
Oh, the days when a webpage was a webpage and not a fileserver. -
[REEVALUATION]Dungeon Master's Guild
#8PS. I reset the poll.
And duplicated my post in his thread in the main forums.