Fields of Challenge · Legacy archive
Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
-
Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#1IMPORTANT STUFF:
You can vote up to 10 times, and can change your votes as the list changes over time by clicking "REMOVE VOTE".
To avoid people "queueing" quest submissions, the next quest will always be chosen randomly from the top 3-5 most popular. We've decided this using Chatbot before, but may change our method in the future.
If you would like to add any ideas to the list, post them on this thread and I will modify the poll.
I will update/reformat this master list any time someone posts to this thread with a new idea. I will also remove ideas that have already been done.
Current List
(see below for a short blurb explaining each quest):
100 Word Submission
Test your powers of brevity by crafting a full submission using 100 words or fewer. 100 Word Submission
Create-a-30s List
A creativity challenge, come up with a list of 30 related NPCs, items, plotlines, etc. Emphasis is on general useability (would a GM want to print your list out to have next to him at the table?) and creativity (can you think of things that haven't been done to death?). See The 30 and The Other 30s for inspiration.
5 in 1, Round Two! (sans heavy rules)
Take five submissions and come up with a brand-new sub that incorporates them all. The only rule is that none of the seed submissions may be your own. If you want an extra challenge, use five random submissions to craft your masterpiece.
Aerial/Sky
Anything that flies, glides or soars through the air -- be it mechanical or natural, sentient or not. Sky-based cultures & religions, places to visit in your air ship -- anything goes!
Agricultural/Farming
A little-used category, Agricultural systems are an oft-overlooked part of every setting. They can range from the delightfully weird to the snoringly mundane, and can be the basis of an entire culture. Civilizations grow things everywhere -- in their homes, in their fields, and even on their bodies. Lets see how weird & wonderful we can make these! See 30 Things That Grow in a Dwarven Beard if you need an example.
Alcoholic Beverages
It's been a long day on the road, and the party is ready for a little R&R. All they want is a drink to help them forget the unspeakable horrors you threw at them in the last dungeon. What do they find on the "Spirits" menu of the local tavern? And what new regrets will they have in the morning?
Automata
Clockwork men, steam mecha and cyber-golems! Not quite golems and not quite robots, automata should have their own flavor and ethos. How do they work in your world?
Bizarre Holidays
The perfect way to add flavor to any exotic locale, holidays present a unique challenge for the prospective world-builder. Is your holiday logical? Does it serve a purpose or is it just some entertaining fluff? How did it begin, and how is it celebrated in the present day?
Brains
Anything to do with brains. Brains as food/energy/magical sources. Brains as captives (or captors). A society of brains working together to achieve their nefarious goals. Whatever you can think to do with them, really.
Call a Rabbit a Smerp
In which the author chooses something mundane and utterly normal and makes it fantastic. Photo searches and dictionaries are both good sources for your seed idea.
Campaign Starters
Parties are often composed of disparate and completely unconnected characters, with wildly different goals and moral compasses. If you have allowed this to happen to your game, all is not lost -- a GM can still find a compelling reason for these people to go on adventures together. Having them meet in a tavern and talk to the "mysterious stranger" is no longer an option. Instead, write a situation that will force the PCs to work together towards a common goal (and hopefully provide them with motivation to stay together afterwards).
Cartoon Characters made Game Characters
Have you ever been watching an animated series and thought to yourself, "this would make such a cool NPC!" Well, now is your chance to bring it to the table. Give us an adaptation of one of your favorite characters and show us how they fit in your setting.
Create a Mentor
Mentors are an important part of any hero's journey -- they provide advice, combat or financial aid, and sometimes bestow important gifts that will aid the hero in his quest. For this quest, create a mentor character for your PCs to interact with. See (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5939.0.html) for more information on the types and functions of mentors.
Exotic Cavalry
Ofttimes the most exciting mounts a PC will encounter are horses and possibly camels. Give your party something exotic to ride around on, and they will remember it! So will it be tame raptors or mini-elephants, mechs or sandworms or the completely unfathomable -- you decide!
Film Noir
Detectives and dames, cops and robbers -- film noir is all about atmosphere and and panache. With its emphasis on the lone hero, it can be hard to bring this genre to the table, but therein lies the challenge. Create something that brings a little hardboiled action into your game.
Genre-Bender
Take an existing sub by another author and rework it so that it fits within a different genre. Take something modern and make it fantasy, something steampunk and make it post-apocalyptic -- there are no limits here but your own creativity.
Genre Franchise
Time to pull out the classics and put a new spin on them. If you have ever wanted to write something into an existing campaign setting -- the Star Wars universe, the Forgotten Realms, DragonLance or even the venerable Star Trek franchise -- now is your chance.
Graphic Attachment Required
What it says on the box. Any sub you submit to this quest must have a graphic accompanying it. Original artwork is encouraged, but existing images may be used (it's a good idea to get the artist/photographer's permission first, though).
Greys, Space Vixens and Bug-Eyed Things
What sort of alien entities are stalking our solar system? In a quest of galactic proportions, you shall craft an ET themed sub to show off your other-worldly imaginings.
Halloween (Dark Fae)
Not all fairy tales have happy endings, and some are downright terrifying. Craft a sub showing off the darker side of Faerie -- entities like the terrible Fairy Queens, The Redcap, Cat Sith, or the other uncountable nightmares that live between this world and the next. Take care on All Hallows Eve, and line your thresholds with salt. Just in case.
Parasites and Diseases
One of the GMs more creative forms of punishment (and plot advancement), a good disease or parasite can create an aura of desperation that is hard to match. Give us maladies of the heart, mind, body and soul that are chilling and creatively sadistic. Or turn the quest on its head and give us more beneficial symbiotes and diseases to "plague" our settings with.
Rebellion/Revolution/Revolts
The time is ripe for a revolution! Give us rabble-rousers, doomsayers, revolutionaries and heroes to lead us through this time of upheaval. Show us the spark that set off the fires of unrest, and the desperate struggles of the authorities to save the system they rely on.
Secret Societies
From the odd and harmless to the sinister and power-hungry, secret societies have always had a place in RPGs. Whether something for the PCs to join, infiltrate or overthrow, they are fun to play around with. Give us your favorite cabal of hidden baddies, do-gooders or all-around meddlers.
Sentient Clothing
"My hat is talking to me."
". . . Really."
"I'm not joking! Said it wants us to go to BlackDeep City."
"What, so it can find an adventurer with better fashion sense?"
"No. It says it knows someone who can help us."
Summer Festivals
It's a hot, dry day on the road and the party has stopped in town for a quick drink and some shelter from the mid-day sun. They intend to move on, but soon notice that the town is in the middle of a celebration. What do they see, and what adventure awaits them if they choose to stay?
Summer Shopping
Uninspired. Please help me write a blurb for this one!
Tattoos and Magic
Spells are often written in scrolls, scrawled across doorways or inscribed into mystic blades. What effects would they have if inked into the skin of a living creature? Think of ways to expand the use of tattoos within your existing magic system, or develop a whole new system centered around body art. The possibilities are only limited by your imagination.
The End of All Days
Apocalypses, doom-sayers and world-enders! The world is crashing down around your party and the End is very near. Show us the death of an entire setting, in vivid detail.
Vampires
Vampires have been so overused (and misused) lately that they have become parodies of themselves. Lets bleed a little life back into the old tropes and imagine new possibilities for the ever-loved (and hated) night stalkers.
Voodoo
Magic and religion of a distinct flavor, voodoo contains a rich source of imagery and language to build upon. Try crafting a sub that taps into voodoo's unique feel, to give GMs something a little different to use in their next game.
Way of the Fist
"Empty your mind, be formless. Shapeless, like water. If you put water into a cup, it becomes the cup. You put water into a bottle and it becomes the bottle. You put it in a teapot it becomes the teapot. Now, water can flow or it can crash. Be water my friend." - Bruce Lee (Jeet Kune Do)
What the Heck is That?!
For a change of pace, the Citadel will provide an unusual image (or two) and you must write a sub on it. No additional guidelines -- this is visual improv for the writer inside.
World Building
Uninspired. Please help me write a blurb for this one!
Just Add Zombies
1. Take popular genre/setting/material
2. Add zombies
3. ???
4. Profit!
As seen on Face Off, the zombie virus infests Alice in Wonderland. Other fun ideas: Wizard of Oz, Lord of the Rings, the A-Team, Cops, The Dukes of Hazzard, Seinfield (anyone notice how bad zombies really smell? whats up with that?). Of course, feel free to take an existing Citadel submission/Region and zombify it, as well.
5x5 Campaign Design Grid
Plot out a whole campaign using 5 quest ideas/seeds. You must post the grid, and a short paragraph explaining each adventure you come up with (one for each cell in the grid = 25). Remember that the whole point of using the 5x5 method is to create points at which your quests intersect, so don't plan on submitting 5 stand-alone quests in one submission. They have to be interrelated. Here's an article explaining the 5x5 method in more detail: The 5x5 Method
Tales of Terror
Create a Tale of Terror, as described on this site: Tales of Terror. Here is a bare-bones template and some submission guidelines to help you out. Only brand-new work is accepted for this quest, but you can feel free to send your ideas over to Tales of Terror if you come up with something that you like.
Quest Idea Holdovers (from previous threads)
. . . minus repeats and quests that were actually created.
Summer Quest Thought (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5939.0.html)
Create a Mentor
Campaign Starter
Genre-Bender
Religions and Cults
Greys, Space Vixens and Bug-Eyed Things - alien cultures and species to populate the universe
Spring Quest? (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5836.0.html)
Parasites and diseases!
The nasties every space explorer and dungeon delver dreads, becoming infected (or infested) by something rarely (or never before) seen by civilization!
Automata: Clockwork men, steam mecha and cyber-golems!
Not every windup toy and clockwork invention is benevolent, some will cheerfully saw through your home with a buzz blade, and others can give mere mortals more power then they dreamed!
Autumn/Winter Quest Brainstorming (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5744.0.html)
Halloween (Dark Fae)
Call a Rabbit a Smerp (take something mundane and utterly normal and make it fantastic)
Cartoon Characters made Game Characters
Film Noir
Vampires
30 Somethings
World Building (http://strolen.com/viewing/World_Building_102_Environment_building_the_MoonHunter_way)
100 Word Submission (http://strolen.com/viewing/100_Word_Submission)
Summer 2011 Quest Brainstorming (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5585.0.html)
5 in 1 sans heavy rules
Tattoos and Magic
Aerial/sky
Genre Franchise (trek etc)
Summer Festivals
Alcoholic beverages
Rebellion/Revolution/Revolts
Agricultural/farming
Way of the Fist', gear and systems for the hand-to-hand fighter
sentient clothing
Graphic Attachment required
brains :)
Summer Shopping (come up with your best urban setting shops)
What the Heck is That?! (where an unusual image is provided and everyone has to write up a sub on it)
Spring quest options! (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5329.0.html)
The End of all Days: apocalypses, doom-sayers and world-enders!
What will the next Quest be? (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,5035.0.html)
Exotic Cavalry (mounts and units)
Voodoo
Winter/Spring Quest Brainstorming (and Poll) (http://strolen.com/guild/index.php/topic,4957.0.html)
Bizarre Holidays
Secret Societies
-
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#2+25 XP for this quest consolidation goodness as well!
(I like this one better :) ) -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#3Does this get sticki-ified? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#4Thanks, Strolen! Both for the XP and for the sticky. :) -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#5OBSOLETE: Check out the new votable list here: http://www.ranker.com/list/citadel-quests/dossta
Strolen, could I perhaps get access to some of the site's graphics to help prettify this thing a bit? Also, you should be able to embed the list somewhere if you like. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#6That's a rather lot of ads. :)
-
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#7Not that I don't appreciate the effort as it is sort of cool.
But you could also create a forum poll with all the options and allow changing of votes, remove options when used and keep the poll updated here.
Have you tried embedding it somewhere? PM me the embed code and I can see if I can get it at least in the forum to see what it looks like. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#8I thought about creating the poll here, but had a few issues. One, I don't think our polling allows for downvotes. And two, I wasn't sure if there was a limit to the number of options we could create (there usually is). Also, how would we handle the number of votes per user? If this runs long enough, they'd eventually use up all of their votes and we'd have to create a new poll, wouldn't we? All of that said, I'm happy to try creating the poll here if that is the Will of the Citadel. :) -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#9It doesn't allow downvoting but why would you need it?
I didn't see a limit on how many choices a poll can have.
Give each user as many votes as you want.
They always have the option of changing their vote which would keep it fresh or if you needed to add more. (as long as you enabled the option to change votes)
I am fine with the way we are doing it though. Depending on our mood and the season, pick out a set that people are interested in and vote on them.
I was hoping to be able to shove that code in this thread but it won't work. I wouldn't really want to start a new page just for the poll either, thing is starting to get scattered. So not sure what we want to do with that at the moment. Leave it where it is and see if it get used? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#10Added the poll to the Citadel proper. I think I would like to modify it a little though, and restrict it to 10 votes per person rather than 40 (since people can change their votes anyway). Can anyone with admin access do this, or do I need to recreate the poll again? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#11Modified it to 10 votes for you/us! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#12Thanks! Let's see if this list gets used. I'd like to start the next quest soon. :D -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#13well, this is fun. Off to vote! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#14What is the "Brains" one exactly anyway? :lol:
I must say, I voted for it and it has me intrigued. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#15
What is the "Brains" one exactly anyway? :lol:
I must say, I voted for it and it has me intrigued.
The original post on it was simply "Brains? Anything related to brains? :lol:". So really, it's pretty open to interpretation. Brains as food, brains as captives, a society of brains, nifty brain medical procedures, types of brains . . . ? If you like any of the quest ideas ideas and want to come up with a coherent blurb for them, I'll update the list with the new info. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#16Not sure about blurbs, but I can adlib a few :P
Greys, Space Vixens and Bug-Eyed Things.
(Wulfhere's quote comes to mind)
"Grab your blaster pistols and check your silver jumpsuits, boys! We've got work to do!"
Alcoholic Beverages
"Last Call. *Hiccup*"
Film Noir
"Frankly my dear, I don't give..."
oops wrong genre, make that...
"Yeaaah, see, we're gonna do it my way, seeee? Yeah, yeaaaah. Mugsy! Bugsy! Get them!"
nope that's just edward g robinson
Bizarre Holidays
"And Festivus doesn't count!"
Way of the Fist
"Avoid, rather than check. Check, rather than hurt. Hurt, rather than maim. Maim, rather than kill. For all life is precious, nor can any be replaced." Master Kan
or
"Kuen yau sum faat - the punch starts from the heart."
or
"Self-defense is an illusion, a dark cloak beneath which lurks a razor-sharp dagger waiting to be plunged into the first unwary victim. Whoever declares that any weapon manufactured today, whether it be a nuclear missile or a .38 special, is created for self-defense should look a little more closely at his own image in the mirror. Either he is a liar or is deceiving himself. Wing Chun Kung Fu is a very sophisticated weapon, nothing else. It is a science of combat, the intent of which is the total incapacitation of an opponent. It is straightforward, efficient and deadly. If you're looking to learn self-defence, don't study Wing Chun. It would be better for you to master the art of invisibility." Bruce Lee
Sentient Clothing
"Shut up, shirt!
100 Word Submission
"And not a single comma more!"
Agricultural/Farming
"Zzzzzzzzzzzz..."
er, i mean
"An Agronomist's Gambit. Do you dare take the Farmer's Challenge?!"
-
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#171. Take popular genre/setting/material
2. Add zombies
3. ???
4. Profit
As seen on Face Off, the zombie virus infests Alice in Wonderland. Other fun ideas: Wizard of Oz, Lord of the Rings, the A-Team, Cops, The Dukes of Hazzard, Seinfield (anyone notice how bad zombies really smell? whats up with that?)
And then I imagined Zombie Kramer crashing through the door while Jerry and the short bald guy run screaming for their lives -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#18Tales of Terror Format is awesome:
http://strolen.com/viewing/4528
Actual rules: http://www.talesofterror.net/submissionguidelines.html -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#19
1. Take popular genre/setting/material
2. Add zombies
3. ???
4. Profit
Added to the poll as "Just add Zombies" -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#20The old 5-in-One quest got me thinking a little about adventure design, and I remembered reading something on critical-hits.com about using a 5x5 grid to plot out a campaign. To me, this sounds like a perfect idea for a challenging quest:
Original aritcle
So the quest would be thus: plot out a whole campaign using 5 quest ideas/seeds. You must post the grid, and a short paragraph explaining each adventure you come up with (one for each cell in the grid = 25). Remember that the whole point of using the 5x5 method is to create points at which your quests intersect, so don't plan on submitting 5 stand-alone quests in one submission. They have to be interrelated.
What do you guys think of this one? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#21
The old 5-in-One quest got me thinking a little about adventure design, and I remembered reading something on critical-hits.com about using a 5x5 grid to plot out a campaign. To me, this sounds like a perfect idea for a challenging quest:
Original aritcle
So the quest would be thus: plot out a whole campaign using 5 quest ideas/seeds. You must post the grid, and a short paragraph explaining each adventure you come up with (one for each cell in the grid = 25). Remember that the whole point of using the 5x5 method is to create points at which your quests intersect, so don't plan on submitting 5 stand-alone quests in one submission. They have to be interrelated.
What do you guys think of this one?
Neat idea! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#22Do we want to pick a quest?
Or we can do round 2 of Citadel Guild submissions and give bonus points for those again? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#23I'd prefer to pick off the list. The guild quest was fun, but I like to have actual voting at the end of a quest. Why don't you throw the top 5 into a random generator and see what we end up with? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#24"What the heck is that!?" Sounds awesome. If a suitable picture could be drudged up I think it would be a lot of fun! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#25Oooh, so when's the next quest start? Do quests start at any particular point in the year, or just when it's arbitrarily decided? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#26Well, normally we start voting and get cracking about a month or two after the last quest has finished voting and a winner is decided. But since the last quest was for the Guilds, there really wasn't a winner. Soo....We're kinda in limbo.
Looking at the votes, the top three currently are (in-order):
What the Heck is That?! (where an unusual image is provided and everyone has to write up a sub on it)
The End of all Days: apocalypses, doom-sayers and world-enders!
5 in 1, Round Two! (sans heavy rules)
I'd say lets either roll a d6 for one of those, or just take the top choice and run with it. It's past time for our questing to begin anew. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#27I agree. The original intent was to pick between the top 3 or 5 so that no one would have an unfair advantage (by writing a sub for the next quest in advance). If people were waiting for me to start the next quest, I'm sorry -- I have no idea how to go about doing that. I just kinda assumed that Strolen would set one off when he was good and ready to. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#28Who is going to tell me when I am good and ready though?
(RL has taken me over recently. Overwhelmed with things happening. If somebody comes up with the quest and description and date range, I will post it!) -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#29Here are the current top 3 picks:
1. What the Heck is That?! (where an unusual image is provided and everyone has to write up a sub on it)
2. The End of all Days: apocalypses, doom-sayers and world-enders!
3. Religions and Cults
Here is the result from our very own ChatBot:
(16:03:32) ChatBot: Dossta rolls 1d3 and gets 3.
Religions and Cults is the winner!!
Description:
What holds more power over a human heart than fear of the unknown? For this quest we seek answers to the eternal questions of life and death, sin and deliverance. Whether you design an entire belief system or simply a backwater cult , modern or ancient, sci-fi or steampunk -- make your religion sing. Gods and prophets, demons, con-artists and mystic rites; from the humblest spirit to the greatest miracle, anything goes! This is your chance to put a new spin or twist on religion, and give us something we haven't seen before.
Duration:
Exactly 4 weeks. Mar 5th -> Apr 2nd
-
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#30. . . or it will be 4 weeks, from whenever someone starts the quest. Dancing monkey made the quest description! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#31Alright, I went ahead and removed the "Religions and Cults" option from the poll, possibly freeing up some votes for some people. Remember that you get to choose your top 10, and can revote whenever you feel like it. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#32Thanks for working it Dossta!!! -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#33
How does one revote? All I can do is look at the current votes and see how I voted.
Alright, I went ahead and removed the "Religions and Cults" option from the poll, possibly freeing up some votes for some people. Remember that you get to choose your top 10, and can revote whenever you feel like it.
-
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#34There used to be a "Remove Vote" option on this poll that would allow you to revote as often as you liked. I'm not sure where it went atm :( Are there any admins willing to take a look at restoring it? -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#35Edit vote enabled. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#36Legal question on the Genre Franchise quest: Is this one even do-able? I know that a lot of people are picky about fan-derived work and intellectual property. Just wanted to make sure it was OK to keep this on the list before I wrote up a summary for it. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#37Create a 30.
Sentient Clothing.
What the heck is that!
My top three choices in ascending order. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#38I like the Sentient clothing too. The problem I see in "What the Heck!" is that there will be some kind of subjectivity in choosing the image, and it can be hard for some people to write on it, and easy for others. On the other hand it may be the ultimate trial of imagination, so what do I know... -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#39In that spirit, I think it might be worthwhile to choose two pictures and let authors choose one to work off of. -
Re: Quest Brainstorming Compilation *OFFICIAL*
#40Just did some major reformatting of the main post. Every quest now has a short explanatory blurb that will hopefully explain each quest to someone who is getting ready to vote. Couldn't think of a blurb for two of them, but ah well.